In 1890 a site was purchased for the building and plans for the church were drawn up by Pasadena architects Frederick Roehrig and Seymour Locke. The building was constructed in 1892. It was through Wallace Hardison’s strong association with the Pasadena Universalist Church that the architectural firm of Roehrig and Locke were selected to design the church building.  The church was designed in the Richardsonian Romanesque style, with its characteristic wide rounded arched windows and openings, the only building remaining in this style in Ventura County.